When a public owner orders extra work that no bid item covers, it pays either an agreed price or force account. On force account, the contractor tracks every labor hour, material ticket and equipment hour, and the owner pays those costs plus markups its specification sets. Under Iowa DOT’s standard specifications, revised October 20, 2026, a $10,400 force account ticket in the example below bills as $12,680, an effective markup of 21.9%.
Who prices force account work
The field engineer or foreman fills out the daily force account sheet: names, hours, equipment and material deliveries. The project accountant turns those sheets into a billing using the owner’s markup rules, and the project manager signs off.
All of them work from the same section of the owner’s specification. Iowa puts it in Article 1109.03, under extra work. Caltrans puts it in Section 9-1.04 of its 2025 Standard Specifications.
How Iowa DOT pays force account work
Article 1109.03 pays each cost type at actual cost plus its own percentage:
- Labor is paid at the wage rate agreed in writing with the Engineer before work starts, for every hour laborers, timekeepers, supervisors and superintendents are engaged on the work. Iowa adds the actual cost of subsistence, travel, health and welfare, pension and other benefits when a collective bargaining agreement or employment contract requires them.
- Iowa adds 35% of the labor and benefits total. The specification says the 35% covers small tools and all other overhead.
- Property damage, liability and workers’ compensation premiums, unemployment insurance contributions and Social Security taxes are paid at actual cost plus 10%. The contractor furnishes evidence of the rates paid.
- Materials are paid at actual delivered cost, including freight and handling shown on receipted bills, plus 15%.
- Equipment, fuel and lubricants are paid at a rental rate based on the average monthly rental rate in Equipment Watch Cost Recovery, agreed in writing before the work. Iowa adds no profit percentage to the rental rate.
The specification treats this compensation as payment in full, including overhead, profit and tools with no rate allowed. A superintendent who splits time between force account and contract work is prorated by the number of people on each class of work in the payroll.
How Caltrans differs
Caltrans also marks labor up 35%, but its labor base is wider. Section 9-1.04B counts the basic wage, health and welfare, pension, vacation, training and other recognized fringe benefits, then adds the labor surcharge percentage from Caltrans’ Labor Surcharge and Equipment Rental Rates book. That surcharge covers workers’ compensation, Social Security, Medicare, federal and state unemployment insurance and state training taxes. Subsistence, travel and authorized supervisors go into the base too, and the 35% applies to the whole sum.
Caltrans says its labor, material and equipment markups cover all delay costs, overhead and profit. On a contract with a time-related overhead bid item, Caltrans drops the markup on the prime’s own force account work to 30% on labor and 10% each on materials and equipment rental.
| Cost | Iowa DOT Article 1109.03 | Caltrans Section 9-1.04 |
|---|---|---|
| Labor | 35% of wages and required benefits | 35% of wages, benefits, labor surcharge, subsistence and travel |
| Payroll taxes, insurance and unemployment | Actual cost plus 10% | Inside the labor base through the labor surcharge |
| Materials | Actual cost with freight plus 15% | Set in Section 9-1.04C |
| Equipment | Equipment Watch Cost Recovery average monthly rental rate with no profit added | Set in Section 9-1.04D |
| Work done by a subcontractor | 10% of the first $50,000 with a $100 minimum, 5% above | 10% of the subcontractor's total including its markups |
Worked example
The figures below are an example. A general contractor on an Iowa DOT bridge job is ordered to remove and replace a buried drainage structure the plans did not show. The crew’s wages and required benefits come to $5,000, the related payroll taxes and insurance to $800, delivered pipe and bedding to $3,000, and an excavator at the agreed rental rate to $1,600.
| Item | Cost ($) | Markup (%) | Markup ($) | Payment ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wages and required fringe benefits | $5,000 | 35 | $1,750 | $6,750 |
| Payroll taxes, insurance and unemployment contributions | $800 | 10 | $80 | $880 |
| Materials with freight and handling | $3,000 | 15 | $450 | $3,450 |
| Equipment at the agreed rental rate | $1,600 | 0 | $0 | $1,600 |
| Total | $10,400 | 21.9 | $2,280 | $12,680 |
Markups add $2,280 to $10,400 of cost. The excavator line carries no markup at all, so the effective rate on the ticket falls as the equipment share rises.
Under the Caltrans labor rule, the same $5,000 of wages and benefits and $800 of surcharge would form one $5,800 base. At 35%, labor would bill $7,830, against $7,630 for the two Iowa labor lines combined. The Caltrans figure applies only the labor rule. Its material and equipment markups would need the full text of Sections 9-1.04C and 9-1.04D.
Subcontracted force account work
When a subcontractor does the extra work, the prime gets a second markup on top of the sub’s billing. The two owners set it differently.
Iowa allows the prime 10% on the first $50,000, with a $100 minimum, and 5% on the portion over $50,000. Caltrans allows a flat 10% on the subcontractor’s total, including the markups in Section 9-1.04, as reimbursement for administrative costs.
| Subcontractor force account total ($) | Iowa prime markup ($) | Iowa markup (%) | Caltrans prime markup ($) | Caltrans markup (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $600 | $100 | 16.7% | $60 | 10.0% |
| $20,000 | $2,000 | 10.0% | $2,000 | 10.0% |
| $80,000 | $6,500 | 8.1% | $8,000 | 10.0% |
| $200,000 | $12,500 | 6.3% | $20,000 | 10.0% |
On an $80,000 sub ticket, Iowa pays the prime $6,500, or 8.1%, and Caltrans pays $8,000. On a $600 ticket the Iowa minimum lifts the markup to $100, or 16.7%. Iowa’s text does not say whether the tiers apply per ticket or per change order, so settle that with the Engineer before the first billing.
Setting it up in Excel
Put each day’s costs in rows with a cost-type column (labor, payroll tax, material, equipment, subcontract) and look up the rate from a small markup table for that owner. For an Iowa job, the prime’s markup on a subcontract total in cell A2 is:
=IF(A2<=50000, MAX(100, 0.10A2), 5000 + 0.05(A2-50000))
For a Caltrans job it is =0.10*A2. Keep the owner’s table on its own sheet, so the estimator can copy the workbook to the next job and swap one tab.
For your own internal rates, the labor burden post shows how to build the payroll cost per hour, and the equipment rate post shows how to compute an owned equipment rate to compare with the rental rate the owner allows.
Records the owner checks
Iowa requires daily force account payrolls in duplicate on the owner’s forms, signed by the inspector and the contractor’s representative. Claims go to the Engineer in triplicate with supporting receipts, no later than the tenth day of the month after the work.
Caltrans compares its own records to the contractor’s daily force account report. Where the two differ, the specification says Caltrans pays only on its own records. Signatures on the Tentative Daily Extra Work Agreement form do not settle payment.
How to use it on your jobs
Compare each owner’s markup with your own overhead and profit. If your overhead and profit on labor, beyond payroll taxes and benefits, run above 35% of wages, force account labor on an Iowa job recovers less than your full rate, and an agreed price may pay better. Track the effective markup on each closed force account ticket, as in the example, and add it to the change order log by cause.
To start, pull the last force account ticket billed on one public job. Recompute it line by line with that owner’s specification, and compare the total with what the owner paid.